Home » Blogging » ONE




Frankly I don’t know what to make of Lowland by Jhumpa Lahiri, I have always considered her to be one of those over rated Indians writing in English. And this time she does fail to keep me interested in a story centered in Kolkata and that too the Tollygunge area. Seems too close to home, too mundane and after about 10 pages I am not really sure why this book was written. It is these kinds of books that make me wonder whether I am being too snooty about writing a book. Somewhere in my mind is a block which says what I write has to be of Universal nature compelling to my readers. However, the current scenario in fiction writing is either sex, fantasy or just plain everyday life and two bit social media fueled philosophy.

I remember my attempts many years ago to write out side my comfort zone. What I did was that I started writing not as the person I was but by stepping into the imaginary shoes of another character who is different from me. What I noticed then, and what has plagued me since then, is my inability to be uniform in my opinions, dialogue as well as thought processes as this other person. My attempts usually ended up looking rather flaky and weightless to me. Especially attempting to write anything beyond my own experiences seemed a difficult task.

But off late I am once again thinking of attempting to be the ring side audience and a narrator in a new story. I would really like to create something new and finish writing a story instead of abandoning it midway because it looks and reads like a silly scribbling of a teenager.

Looking at oneself with too critical an eye can sometimes prove to be a hindrance.

Let’s just say I owe it to the E.L. James, the Sylvia Day, Chetan Bhagat & now Jhumpa Lahiri, to actually sit down and write a story I want to tell and not worry whether the reader will like to read it or not.




4 thoughts on “ONE

  1. yes Please start writing yourself 🙂

    And at the same time Jhumpa lahiri is not the same as Sylvia day & chetan bhagat. She is over rated alright but atleast writes “correct” & proper English. Also not as flippant and silly as the other two. Also for the first time she has done considerable research for Lowland, on the Naxalite movement of Bengal.
    All in all ” India” is always exotic to firangis and in the west, therein lies her appeal


    • Yes Ishita, she may not be in the same league as Chetan’s or Sylvia’s but in matter of subject and story telling she isn;t a pioneer either… not someone i would consider to be a great example of Indians writing in english. I found Lowland quite pointless. She seems way too much tragic in her outlook.


  2. You summed it up quite well with that word “pointless”. I found the novel quite ordinary, not really worth a Booker nomination. But then, she has an aura about her that makes people go gaga over anything and everything she writes. Have you read Unaccustomed Earth? I didn’t like too many stories there too.


    • Thank you for for your comment Rashi.

      I did read Unaccustomed Earth, liked some of the stories. What bothers me is the goal and vibe of her stories, they seem tad mundane and negative at the same time. I may be too harsh in my judgement about her. Bt I don’t know why she has got the following that she has, is it because in d foreign land she is exotic ? I wonder.


Would like to hear your opinion, please comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s